Understand the difference between OAN, NSA, and STSA. When comparing grades, first confirm the parameter name, unit, and test method.
Similar parameter names do not mean the same measurement
ASTM D2414 covers oil absorption number (OAN) of carbon black. ASTM D6556 covers total and external surface area of carbon black by nitrogen adsorption. They describe different measurements. Oil absorption and surface area should not be converted into each other, and different surface-area parameters should not be treated as the same merely because their names look similar.
Organize the data into a comparable table
Item to review
What to confirm
Oil absorption
Abbreviation, unit, method, and method version
Surface area
Total or external surface area, plus the specific method and unit
Nature of the value
Typical value, specification range, or a measured result from a given batch
Applicability
Formulation, process, and finished-product test requirements
After comparing parameters, compare actual results
It is best to obtain complete data for the same grade first, then shortlist candidates worth sampling. If suppliers use different methods or units, confirm comparability before ranking the numbers as higher or lower performance. A parameter table is a starting point; final grade selection still needs to be verified in the actual system.